SQL vs NoSQL: When to use and key differences

Choosing between SQL and NoSQL databases is a crucial decision that can significantly impact your project's success. This guide provides an in-depth comparison of SQL vs NoSQL, helping you understand their differences and choose the right database type for your needs.

SQL vs NoSQL Overview

1. SQL vs NoSQL: Key Differences
2. SQL vs NoSQL Performance Comparison
3. Practical Examples: SQL vs NoSQL in Action
4. SQL to NoSQL Query Mapping Examples
5. Popular Backend Services and Their Database Types
6. Conclusion: Making the Right Choice

SQL vs NoSQL: Key Differences

Before diving into the details of each database type, let's compare the key differences between SQL and NoSQL:

Feature	SQL Databases	NoSQL Databases
Data Model	Structured, table-based	Flexible (document, key-value, graph, etc.)
Schema	Predefined, fixed	Dynamic, flexible
Scalability	Vertical	Horizontal
ACID Compliance	Yes	Varies (some offer ACID compliance)
Consistency	Strong	Eventual (in most cases)
Use Cases	Complex queries, transactions	High traffic, big data, real-time web apps

What is ACID?

ACID is an acronym that stands for Atomicity, Consistency, Isolation, and Durability. These properties ensure database transactions are processed reliably:

• Atomicity: All operations in a transaction succeed or the entire transaction is rolled back.
• Consistency: A transaction brings the database from one valid state to another.
• Isolation: Concurrent transactions do not interfere with each other.
• Durability: Once a transaction is committed, it remains so, even in the event of power loss or system failures.

SQL databases are known for strong ACID compliance, while NoSQL databases may sacrifice some ACID properties for increased performance and scalability.

SQL vs NoSQL Performance Comparison

Aspect	SQL	NoSQL
Read Performance	Excellent for complex queries	Excellent for simple queries
Write Performance	Good, but can slow with scale	Excellent, especially at scale
Scalability	Vertical (harder to scale)	Horizontal (easier to scale)
Large Datasets	Can struggle with very large datasets	Handles large datasets well
Complex Joins	Excellent	Limited or not supported

The performance difference between SQL and NoSQL can vary greatly depending on the specific use case and implementation.

Practical Examples: SQL vs NoSQL in Action

Let's compare how you might implement a simple data storage and retrieval operation in both SQL and NoSQL. These examples highlight the syntactical and conceptual differences between the two approaches.

SQL Example (using PostgreSQL):

-- Create a table
CREATE TABLE items (
    id SERIAL PRIMARY KEY,
    name VARCHAR(100),
    category VARCHAR(50)
);

-- Insert data
INSERT INTO items (name, category) VALUES ('Hammer', 'tools');

-- Retrieve data
SELECT * FROM items WHERE category = 'tools';

NoSQL Example (using Codehooks.io API):

import { app, datastore } from 'codehooks-js'

// Store data
app.post('/items', async (req, res) => {
    const conn = await datastore.open();    
    const result = await conn.insertOne('items', req.body);
    res.json(result);
})

// Retrieve data
app.get('/items', async (req, res) => {
    const conn = await datastore.open(); 
    conn.getMany('items', { category: 'tools' }).json(res);
})

As demonstrated, SQL requires a predefined schema and uses structured query language, while NoSQL offers a more flexible, schema-less approach with a simpler API. Each has its advantages depending on your specific use case.

SQL vs NoSQL: Query Examples for comparison

The following list shows SQL example statements expressed as NoSQL queries. Note that this is specific to codehooks.io (which use a query language similar to MongoDB). Read more about codehooks.io NoSQL query language in the codehooks.io documentation.

SELECT * FROM users

/*
* SQL statement: 
* SELECT * FROM users
* expressed as a nosql database query
*/
const db = await Datastore.open();
db.find('users')

SELECT user_id, status FROM users

const query = {};
const opt = {
    hints: {$fields: {user_id: 1, status: 1}}
}
db.find('users', query, opt)

SELECT * FROM users  WHERE status = "A"

const query = {status: "A"};
db.find('users', query)

SELECT * FROM users  WHERE status != "A"

const query = {"status":{"$not":"A"}}
db.find('users', query)

SELECT * FROM users  WHERE status = "A" AND age = 50

const query = {"status": "A", "age": 50 }
db.find('users', query)

SELECT * FROM users  WHERE status = "A" OR age = 50

const query = { "$or": [ { "status": "A" } ,{ "age": 50 } ] }
db.find('users', query)

SELECT * FROM users  WHERE age > 25

const query = { "age": { "$gt": 25 } }
db.find('users', query)

SELECT * FROM users  WHERE user_id like "bc%"

const query = { "user_id": /^bc/}
db.find('users', query)

SELECT * FROM users  WHERE status = "A" ORDER BY name ASC

// Use the CLI to create a sorted index
// $ codehooks createindex --collection users --index name
const query = { "status": "A" }
const opt = {
    sort: {"name": 1}
}
db.find('users', query, opt)

SELECT * FROM users  WHERE status = "A" ORDER BY name DESC

// Use the CLI to create a sorted index
// $ codehooks createindex --collection users --index name
const query = { "status": "A" }
const opt = {
    sort: {"name": -1}
}
db.find('users', query, opt)

SELECT COUNT(*) FROM users

const query = {}
const opt = {
    hints: {$onlycount: true}, 
}
db.find('users', query, opt)

SELECT COUNT(*) FROM users WHERE age > 30

const query = {age: {$gt: 30}}
const opt = {
    hints: {$onlycount: true}
}
db.find('users', query, opt)

SELECT * FROM users LIMIT 1

const query = {}
const opt = { limit: 1 }
db.find('users', query, opt)

SELECT * FROM users LIMIT 5 SKIP 10

const query = {}
const opt = {
    limit: 5,
    offset: 10
}
db.find('users', query, opt)

SQL vs NoSQL: Best Use Cases

SQL Use Cases	NoSQL Use Cases
Financial systems	Real-time big data
ERP systems	Content management
CRM applications	IoT applications
E-commerce platforms	Social networks
Legacy systems migration	Gaming applications

Choose SQL when you need ACID compliance, complex queries, and have a well-defined, stable schema. Opt for NoSQL when dealing with large volumes of unstructured data, requiring high scalability, or needing rapid development with changing data models.

Popular Backend Services and Their Database Types

When choosing a backend service for your project, it's important to understand which database type they use. Here's a list of popular backend services and their primary database types:

Service	Primary Database Type	Notes
Supabase	SQL (PostgreSQL)	Offers real-time capabilities and PostgREST API
Firebase	NoSQL	Uses Cloud Firestore, a document-based NoSQL database
MongoDB Atlas	NoSQL	Managed MongoDB service, document-based NoSQL
AWS RDS	SQL	Supports multiple SQL engines (MySQL, PostgreSQL, etc.)
Restdb.io	NoSQL	Document-based NoSQL with a REST API
Codehooks.io	NoSQL	Flexible NoSQL with built-in API and serverless functions
Fauna	Multi-model	Supports both relational and document models
Azure Cosmos DB	Multi-model	Supports multiple NoSQL models (document, key-value, graph)
Google Cloud Datastore	NoSQL	Schemaless NoSQL datastore
Amazon DynamoDB	NoSQL	Key-value and document database

This list showcases the diversity of database options available in modern backend services. Some services, like Fauna and Azure Cosmos DB, even offer multi-model capabilities, allowing you to leverage both SQL and NoSQL paradigms within a single service.

When selecting a backend service, consider not only the database type but also factors such as:

• Scalability and performance
• Pricing model (fixed or usage based)
• Integration with other services
• Developer experience and tooling
• Compliance and security features

Remember that the best choice depends on your specific project requirements, expected data volume, and development team's expertise.

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice

Choosing between SQL and NoSQL depends on your specific project requirements. Consider factors such as data structure, scalability needs, consistency requirements, and development flexibility when making your decision.

SQL might be the better choice if you need:

• Strong data consistency
• Complex queries and transactions
• A predefined, stable schema

NoSQL could be more suitable if you require:

• Flexibility in data structure
• High scalability for large amounts of data
• Faster performance for simple read/write operations

Remember, it's not always an either-or decision. Some projects benefit from using both SQL and NoSQL databases to leverage the strengths of each.

At Codehooks.io, we offer a powerful NoSQL Database API that combines the flexibility of NoSQL with the ease of use of a REST API. It's an excellent choice for projects that require rapid development and scalability.

---

Ready to explore NoSQL for your project? Check out the Codehooks.io NoSQL Database API to get started.